Your Argument is good, but you are still Wrong

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin

Invalid vs Incorrect

There’s a common myth that arguments which are valid always have a correct conclusion. The best Critical Thinking students know better. Invalid arguments can be correct, and valid arguments can be incorrect. Here are some examples:

Invalid argument with correct conclusion

IF: All cats have fur,

IF: Pingu is a cat,

THEN: Lassie the dog has fur.

If we didn’t like this argument, we could completely refute it. Imagine an alien from outer-space coming across this argument. They could say something like:

“This argument is invalid because it is illogical. There is no reason from the argument why Lassie should have fur; Lassie is not even mentioned in the premises.

They could then go on to make a counter argument:

IF: Lassie is often in the water,

IF: Water animals from earth often do not have fur,

THEN: Lassie probably does not have fur.

This argument is valid, because the conclusion logically flows from the premises.

The strange thing is however, that the first (invalid) conclusion was correct, and the new (valid) conclusion is incorrect. Lassie the dog has beautiful fur!

Border Collie

Let’s look at another valid argument with an incorrect conclusion:

Valid argument with incorrect conclusion

IF: The median average UK income is £27,600

THEN: Everyone probably earns around £27,600.

This kind of argument, just like the second Lassie argument above is called an inductive argument because it leads from a specific argument into a more general conclusion. Inductive arguments are not necessarily true, even when they are valid. We add a “probably” to the conclusion to show this. This is an excellent example of a strong, inductive argument, with good evidence. It is a valid argument.

Unfortunately, the conclusion is still incorrect. We can argue against it like this:

“Many people in the UK are not in paid employment at all, or are in part time work and they will not earn an income at all. In the UK there is also great wage inequality. Some people will earn much more than that, and some workers, particularly from minority groups, will earn less.”

graph showing earnings of population year after year

Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Refuting Arguments

Whether an argument is valid or invalid is especially important because it affects how we respond.

To properly argue a case, we need to explain why we disagree with the original argument, before we make our new argument to replace it.

When the argument is invalid, we can do this simply by explaining its logical inconsistencies. When an argument is valid, but just incorrect, we have to find a way to explain the evidence better using our new argument.

Are your arguments rusty?  ADL offers a distance learning University Preparation Package for just £60, which gives you a full university level briefing in Critical Thinking and Academic Writing. Three marked assignments and unlimited support are included. Come and learn to think!

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on whatsapp

LEAVE A REPLY

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on whatsapp

BLOG CATEGORIES

MOST POPULAR

Are ad hominem attacks always invalid?

Valid Arguments In order to be valid, an argument has to be based on evidence. For example, we might say: “Tigers can produce milk…” Or “Wildlife brings tourism…“ However, these are not valid arguments unless we give some evidence, or cite a source: “… Since tigers are mammals and all female mammals can lactate for

Read More »

Your Argument is good, but you are still Wrong

Invalid vs Incorrect There’s a common myth that arguments which are valid always have a correct conclusion. The best Critical Thinking students know better. Invalid arguments can be correct, and valid arguments can be incorrect. Here are some examples: Invalid argument with correct conclusion IF: All cats have fur, IF: Pingu is a cat, THEN:

Read More »

Cataracts – not just an older person’s condition

  A cataract is a clouding of the lens in the eye. Vision becomes blurred because the cataract interferes with sight, like a veil in front of the eye. Many individuals over 60 have cataracts and most of these can be treated successfully. The risk for cataracts increases as we age, but the average age for

Read More »

Check these things before Submitting your next assignment

You have spent lots of time researching, working hard to produce a top quality assignment that will be appreciated by your tutor. You have timed it well; your favourite TV programme is about to start, you have some tasty food waiting for you. It’s now time to submit that assignment and wait for a response.

Read More »

SIGNUP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER

Scroll to Top